Countries sending alleged ‘faulty’ COVID-19 test kits, face masks back to China

Marje Pelayo   •   March 30, 2020   •   841

MANILA, Philippines – Several countries are sending imported medical supplies back to China after they were reportedly found defective.

The latest is the Netherlands, which ordered a recall of more than 600,000 alleged substandard face masks.

The Dutch government received on March 21 shipments of about 1.3 million face masks.

But the government’s Ministry of Health said the rest of the shipment “was immediately put on hold and has not been distributed.”

“A second test also revealed that the masks did not meet the quality norms. Now it has been decided not to use any of this shipment,” the Dutch Health Ministry said in a statement.

The imported FFP2 masks or N95 masks don’t provide full-face protection and the filters were also defective, claimed the Ministry.

Following the revealed defects, Dutch authorities said they will be stricter by doing extra standard testing to all arriving medical supplies shipment.

Prior to this, the Spanish government last week announced it would send back the rapid test kits it imported from a company in China after tests revealed only 30% detection rate.

Spain said the kits, which came from a national supplier, were ‘CE-Certified’ and passed the European standards.

However, the Chinese Embassy in Spain revealed that the supplier Shenzhen Bioeasy Biotechnology is not licensed nor registered under the National Administration of Medical Products of China to sell such medical products.

Despite the controversy, China vowed to replace the defective test kits delivered to Spain.

Countries like Turkey and the Czech Republic were also among countries that reported ‘faulty’ rapid test kits from China.

In the Philippines, meanwhile, the Department of Health (DOH) found that several COVID-19 test kits yielded only a 40% accuracy rate.

But the DOH clarified that those defective kits were not the ones from China but a brand that was said to have been donated by a private local group.

Sa ngalan po ng Kagawaran humihingi po kami ng paumanhin sa naidulot nitong pagkalito sa nasabi ko po kahapon. Sana po ay na- klaro na po namin ang isyu na ito [In behalf of the Department we apologize for the confusion caused by what I mentioned yesterday. We hope that we have clarified this issue,” said DOH Spokesperson Maria Rosario Vergeire.

The DOH stressed that the COVID-19 tests kits imported from China and were delivered to the Philippines, have passed the World Health Organization (WHO) standards. MNP (with reports from Harlene Delgado)

FDA recalls locally-made COVID-19 test kits for ‘minor defects’

Marje Pelayo   •   May 21, 2020

MANILA, Philippines — Some ‘minor defects’ have been seen in the test kits made by the University of the Philippines – National Institute of Health (UP-NIH), according to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

This prompted the agency to order the recall of all locally-made coronavirus disease (COVID-19) test kits and stop its use in medical facilities until the problem is resolved.

Specifically, FDA Director Eric Domingo said evidence of contamination had been traced in the reagents that were used in the test kits of UP-NIH; hence, they should not be sold or used for now.

The said locally-made test kits were approved for use by the FDA in April.

Nonetheless, Health Spokesperson Undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire ascertained that the UP-NIH is soon to complete correcting the deficiencies in their test kits. 

“They are in the final stages of correcting the identified deficiencies of the kits by RITM and hopefully by next week they can be re-validated by RITM and we can already use the UP testing kits,” Vergeire said. 

As regards the rapid antibody test kits, Malacañang maintained that local government units (LGU) may still use the said kits despite claims by medical societies that the use of such would be a waste of resources when they only give false results. 

According to Presidential Spokesperson Secretary Harry to  Roque, the LGUs just need to confirm the results of the rapid antibody test kits through real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (rRT-PCR) test within the succeeding 14 days. 

Sa ngayon po, dahil po wala pa tayong sapat na kakayahan at dahil tayo po ay nagbi-build up pa lang ng capacity ng PCR testing, siguro naman walang mawawala kung ira-rapid testing natin ang gusting magpa-rapid testing at yung mga positive, ipa-verify natin sa PCR [For now, since we do not have enough capacity yet and we are still building up our PCR testing capacity, there’s no harm if we still proceed with rapid testing to those who request it, and if it yields a positive result, then have it confirmed through PCR],” Roque explained.

 FDA-approved rapid test kits costs around P3,500 and up depending on the source company and the country of origin. MNP (with reports Aiko Miguel)

DOH admits COVID-19 testing capacity still below 8,000 to 10,000 daily target

Marje Pelayo   •   April 29, 2020

MANILA, Philippines — The Department of Health (DOH) on Wednesday admitted that the country’s testing capacity for coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is still below the target.

The Department had planned to expand its mass testing to 8,000 – 10,000 tests daily starting Thursday (April 30).

But, according to Health Undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire, they may not be able to achieve the target as scheduled.

Mukhang hindi po aabot dito sa walong libo for April 30, though sinusubukan natin dahil ngayon po dumating na ang cartridges natin for GeneXpert [I don’t think we can achieve the 8,000 target for April 30 though we are trying, especially with the arrival of the cartridges for GeneXpert,]” the official said.

The DOH was able to conduct a total of 6,320 tests on Tuesday (April 28) in 19 licensed testing laboratories across the country. 

Vergeire noted the recent scaling down of operations at the Research Institute for Tropical Medicine (RITM) as one reason for the delay in testing of samples which left the processing of results pending for about a week.

The RITM has just resumed full operations on Sunday after more than 30 of its COVID-19 positive medical staff recovered from the disease.

With the use of GeneXpert test kits, the DOH expects the results to be out within 45 minutes which will definitely improve the country’s testing capacity and hopefully achieve its daily target.

“But ngayon po itong ating goal ay pilit na maabot, aabutin [We will try hard to achieve our goal in] the coming days as all the resources had been falling in coming from private side and coming from the government,” Vergeire said.

Meanwhile, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has added a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test kit from Singapore and two brands of rapid antibody test kit from Germany and China among the list of approved test kits that may be used in hospitals across the country.

To date, the country has a total of 33 FDA-approved PCR-based test kits and 24 rapid antibody test kits. 

The DOH reminds the public, however, that these test kits may only be administered by licensed doctors and experts who are also authorized to interpret test results. –MNP (with details from Aiko Miguel)

DOH doesn’t recommend rapid antibody test kits for expanded mass testing

Marje Pelayo   •   April 15, 2020

MANILA, Philippines — President Rodrigo Duterte has ordered the procurement of two million rapid antibody test kits and directed the Office of the Civil Defense (OCD) to facilitate the process.

“I will clear the way by ordering the purchase, tutal walang FDA local (since the local FDA doesn’t have kits). But what we are trying to buy outside, it is approved by the US-FDA. So, in a sense almost all: what we eat, the products of all sorts that we buy, if it is FDA-approved, galing Amerika, kampante tayo niyan (it comes from America, we are confident),” the President said.

But for the Department of Health (DOH), this kind of test kit is not recommendable for mass testing and warns that they might yield inaccurate results.

“Nakapaloob sa Department Circular No. 2020-160 na ang rapid test kit ay hindi po recommended para sa mass testing (Department Circular No. 2020-160 states that rapid test kits are not recommended for mass testing), ” explained DOH Undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire.

Over the counter ay hindi rin po at hindi rin puwede sa self-testing (Over the counter test kits are not recommended. Self-testing is also not allowed),” she added.

Vergeire said results shown by rapid antibody test kits must still be confirmed through the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) based test used in laboratories like the Research Institute for Tropical Medicine (RITM) and the subnational laboratories.

Ang paggamit ng rapid antibody test ay maaring mag-resulta sa [The use of rapid antibody test kits may yield] false negative results,” the official explained.

Ibig pong sabihin nito ay kahit negative ang lumabas na resulta sa rapid test kit maaaring positibo pa rin ang pasyente sa (It might appear that the results are negative when in fact the person is positive for) COVID-19,” she added.

Meanwhile, the FDA already approved 37 kinds of test kits — 26 are PCR based and 11 are rapid antibody test kits.

Currently, the country has 16 Stage-5 accredited laboratories where confirmatory tests for COVID-19 are being done. MNP (with details from Aiko Miguel)


The Philippine Broadcast Hub

UNTV, 915 Barangay Philam,

EDSA, Quezon City M.M. 1104

(+632) 8396-8688 (Tel) (General inquiries)


UNTV is a major TV broadcast network with 24-hour programming. An Ultra High Frequency station with strong brand content that appeal to everyone, UNTV is one of the most trusted and successful Philippine networks that guarantees wholesome and quality viewing experience.